Were it not for the Clash, punk would have been just a sneer
It might have been a touch of the Rip Van Winkles, or it may have all happened before I launched the blog last summer but every now and then something that was seemingly important just passes me by. I also may well be telling you something you knew about last Spring and if that’s the case sorry – if not then you’ll be glad you dropped by. I think the reality was I read about this briefly, meant to return to it and then got distracted by the need to pay a bill or visit the dentist or something.
I’m coming at this project from the sidelines but if you’ve read the book or been involved with ‘Let Fury Have the Hour’ please feel free to write in and let me know what you thought. I’d seen the book online and added it to my bucket list of Clash tasks which seems to somehow grow as the years roll by. The book had mixed reviews and perhaps the documentary film project is a natural (or better?) outcome for the compendium of research undertaken by author Antoninio D’Ambrosio. The official blurb on the book does little to capture you but the more objective Publisher’s Weekly overview does leave you wanting to read more (the risk being you may have read much of it before).
“Were it not for the Clash, punk would have been just a sneer, a safety pin, and a pair of bondage trousers,” writes Billy Bragg, and documentarian/activist D’Ambrosio proves it with this gathering of skillfully selected articles and essays on Clash front man Joe Strummer (1952–2002), from the likes of Lester Bangs, Chuck D, Greil Marcus and D’Ambrosio himself. Most contributions consider the highly politicized early years of “the only band that mattered,” its commercial U.S. breakthrough in 1983 as well as its imminent demise, and Strummer’s role as lyricist and political agitator. Although a few essays discuss the political ambiguity of some of Strummer’s songs, they mostly praise the outspoken singer/guitarist’s commitment to confronting racism, classism and capitalism at a time when punk bands were apolitical or nihilistic. In a 1979 essay, Lester Bangs credits the Clash with forging “the missing link between black music and white noise.” Other pieces chronicle Strummer’s stints as a film score composer and actor and his ongoing forays into multicultural music. Some essays lean toward a preachy interpretation of Strummer’s humanist philosophy, but the best invoke irresistible excitement as they describe beer-soaked early Clash shows and the message of hope the band gave to kids rebelling against what they saw as the oppressive conservatism and systemic self-loathing of Thatcherite England”
I think the premise for the book was worthy of applause, it takes the vehicle of Joe Strummer and specifically the ‘message’ of The Clash to assess the power of rock music to filter to the great unwashed a message of inclusion, activism and change, but from a platform of democracy. During
my reflective moments I know that The Clash altered my stance on so many things – arriving in my life a few years before girls distracted me and at an age where questioning and challenging the status quo was germinating in me waiting to see the light of day. Whether this ability was something that The Clash sat down and planned/plotted (research suggests yes with the active boot up the arse of the band’s management) wasn’t the point. Music is a results based service and The Clash were broadcasting to legions of bored, agitated and primarily younger men and women who wanted a band that mattered – a band that were worth caring about.
Do you even remember being 14 years old? I do, at that age a year following a band seemed to be a significant commitment of time, a 3 or 4 year relationship signified a band that reflected who you were and what you valued, it seemed they had been there for you forever. For me – I had the Clash as a daily active concern from early ’79 to late ’83 within a year of Mick Jones being kicked out I understood the initial band were finished but my loyalty to the ideas remained. I’d gone from being twelve to leaving home, from having no clue to feeling aware of unions, central america, and the wrongs of the corporations that bashed around the working man. The US was no longer just the home of hamburgers and Disneyland but now had the shadow of Vietnam and the Cold War dragging behind it. My education in addition to school was The Clash, my need to learn more initially came from a band – some would call that naive but I thought it was pivotal.
I’ll do more research on the book and film….so this post was a bit premature eh? One thing I’m finding myself less and less comfortable with however is the separation of The Clash and Strummer – especially as a political artist – I think it is one and the same entity.
Further reading: Link to the official site is here. An in-depth article about The Clash by D’Ambrosio appears here. LA Weekly blog article is also good.
_20110619215502.png)
I completely agree with you regarding learning so much from the Clash. For me, school and history books we so useless. Boring. Pointless. And at 14, getting through my thick, selfish, self-absorbed head was definitely a job.
Anyways, this makes me think of ‘Straight to Hell.’ The first time I heard that song I thought ‘what is this guy talking about? This song makes no sense at all and I think I might be kind of offended. And he’s talking about hell, and I don’t think that would make my mom very happy.’ Just typing that makes me laugh
My intrigue, of course, led to my first bit of education about war and life from The Clash’s point of view. I can’t tell you how many books and topics I have read just because I heard about it in a Clash song. Good damn poets, those punks.
Great post. Please keep us updated on the release of a dvd release or any more info on this. I also thought a nice touch would maybe to have Joe’s bbc radio show on a player. Thank you.
I first heard the Clash two years ago, when I was 13.
I totally understand what you, and Kara, say about the education of the world and then wanting to find out more, just because there was a two line mention in a song. I also have read books about things I never dreamt would intrest me, and yet theres always another question…
I’m still in compulsory education, and I can’t deny that the Clash have added another dimension to everything we study. Its even better when your teacher was a Clash fan back when they were a kid too…
Sophie,
Thanks – I really like hearing that the added value of the lyrics and the concerns of the band have held their appeal despite the years rolling by. There is so much music out there that says nothing a part from ‘have a good time’ or focuses on relationships – that I think bands that say/said something hold a higher place in the great scheme of things.
T
It’s amazing to me (and great) that hearing just one song can open up a whole new way of looking at things as you explore a band. Thanks for your message Kara
I think some people in that trailer are genuine fans but xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. what a fake. just seems like a bandwagon jumper to me to benefit themselves. just my opinion..
While I respect your opinion – I’m hoping to interview the chap behind the project so I can’t publish your comment as it stands. I do welcome you to rephrase it.
I would not read this book. I just get that feeling it would wind me up.
I just didnt really care for the woman from SEIU. thats just my opinion but i dont mind if you interview the guy who made it, id probly read it