The Clash Cup Round 2 Match 11
Good evening everyone how was your Saturday then? I just got home from playing football where it was a lovely 104f when we started but good fun nevertheless, in fact I imagined the ball was a particular person’s head (see previous post) so putting my boot through the ball had an extra level of satisfaction tonight. If this is your first visit your timing is good as it’s time for another edition of The Clash Cup. A very simple process that allows you to vote for your favourite Clash song via the blog; round one included every Clash song I could find and we are now well into round two. The pairings are completely at random and you can vote once over the next four or five days. Before seeing which names come out of the bag tonight we need to recap the previous battle from earlier in the month which was quite a close run thing.
Justice Tonight/Kick It Over defeated The City of The Dead 37 – 30
That was quite the result, it was close from the very beginning and the original lead set by the eventual winner got smaller and larger until it ended as a very tight affair. As it stands, the City of The Dead looks set to continue into round three as one of the most successful runners up however that is subject to change based on the overall results from this round. I know I had a hard time picking between these two and it seemed so did you. The battle of the B-Sides indeed! Now we’ll use the random number generator for the next two:
Round 2 Match 11
Four Horseman versus English Civil War
I do believe we have another difficult decision on our hands based on the above. I know both songs will get good support but on this occasion I know instantly which one I’ll pick but don’t let my thoughts influence what you do nor should you let the current votes impact your decision because I do see some big changes from day to day with these votes. This could be another situation where the runner-up gets enough support to make it into round three or perhaps I’m totally misjudging how the votes will fall. For me, English Civil War was one of the first Clash songs that I became completely obsessed with as a kid and I still find it’s one that sends my blood racing. Great to sing along to and then one of the first songs I learned to play very badly on guitar when I eventually learned how to do many years later, still learning don’t hold your breath. On the other hand Four Horsemen was never amongst my top 10 tracks from London Calling which means it will probably go and win this handsomely.
Form book:
Round 1 – Four Horsemen defeated Lover’s Rock 71% of the vote
Round 1 – English Civil War lost to London’s Burning with 31% of the vote but stayed in the competition due to most votes for a runner-up in round one
Odds:
I’d completely forgotten that English Civil War had lost in round one but got a lot of votes which enabled it to continue on. I’ve actually read that a lot of people felt the song was too gimmicky and the lyrics too naive, not to mention the fact it wasn’t technically an original composition either. I may be in the minority willing it to go forward in The Clash Cup although I think it’s probably not going to make it this time. London Calling just has so much support spread across its 19 tracks so that songs from the album will usually be a favourite until we get to the final 32.
Stuff:
When people listen to songs that are more than a decade old or so the phrase ‘how has it dated’ often comes up. My opinion for what it’s worth is that Four Horsemen even years ago was the only track on London Calling where the production maybe didn’t bring out the best in the song and I’d say the passing of time emphasizes that a little bit more. As for English Civil War it technically a Clash cover version with the tune of course taken from Johnny Comes Marching Home and/or Johnny I Hardly Knew Ye. So whether the origin of the folk song is American or Irish is up in the air. I would guess Irish and then rewritten during the Civil War by Irish-Americans as a reworked folk song to mark the brutal war. Common sense tells me my personal affection for English Civil War came from knowing it from when I was a toddler although I don’t remember attending any Irish folk sessions it could be my Mum’s fault I would venture (yes she’s a Dubliner, not one of the Dubliners mind you, I don’t want to misrepresent her).
As always I encourage you to give both songs a final listen before voting which you can do by way of clicking the options that follow. Voting itself is equally easy but all votes are final, if you feel like justifying your decision or indecision please feel free to add your comments as it would be nice to hear from you. As for the versions, I almost forgot Animal Farm was one of the most influential ‘proper’ books that resonated with me at an early age and as you know the cover of the English Civil War 45rpm sleeve featured the aforementioned conflicted farm animals. Don’t know why that came up but there you have it and if you resort to read one book this year that you’ve never read, try that one or To kill a Mockingbird. Back on track here is Four Horsemen which features Joe adding vocals from the making of London Calling DVD with Guy Stevens working his magic. (Warning for the ladies tasty Paul Simonon alert on the video). As for English Civil War it just had to be the Rude Boy clip/outtake where Strummer looks positively charged and ready to shout the lyrics through your head if need be.
Happy voting, thanks for voting and I will speak to you very soon.
Which Clash Song Stays in The Clash Cup? Round 2 match 11
- Four Horsemen (32%, 19 Votes)
- English Civil War (68%, 39 Votes)
Total Voters: 59



_20110619215502.png)