Clash Cup Round 2 Match 17
The Clash Cup (noun) 1. An online vote by of some of the most knowledgeable fans of The Clash ever assembled in one place (that’s you) aimed ultimately to determine the best 32,16 and 8 Clash songs ever recorded.
The concept is as simple as the execution of course and may I remind you that all of the pairings that I need you to vote on are created entirely at random. The polls only have three rules, they are open for five days, every vote matters as the best runners up in terms of total percentage are eligible to remain the competition and you can only vote once so please make your decision carefully. We’ve been doing this for a long time and I know the intervals between voting have been too long, long enough to suggest I’d be better equipped to run the political system of a banana republic than any sort of online voting system but its been a year of resolutions for me and another is to get The Clash Cup back on track – starting tonight.
We’re currently in round two and before introducing the songs I’d appreciate you voting on it would be time to look back at the result of our last gathering which took place quite some time ago, it was a close vote and an all Sandinista! affair.
The Street Parade defeated Broadway 35-27
Two strong songs that both exhibited a style that The Clash had never really experimented with prior to the fourth album and both provide good evidence of the quality of songs ‘tucked away’ on that triple album. I’d suggest just with hindsight that if either song were on Combat Rock instead it would be considered amongst the best songs of the album. The setting of Sandinista! in it’s extravagant 36 song breadth sometimes makes you forget how many great Clash songs were on there. While it won’t quite (today, for me) make the category of ‘best Clash album’ I still think it has aged the best and holds excellent lasting appeal. The Street Parade winning shocked me a little as I thought Broadway would edge a very close vote. Tell me I’m wrong but I think Street Parade has taken on a more elegant or special place since the death of Joe Strummer. It has for me but there’s no reason to assume it did for you.
Let’s get straight down to business with the next pair and please forgive me for the shorter than usual pre-match festivities but I’m knackered tonight. The random number generator is buzzing away so let’s see what we have:
Clash Cup Round 2 Match 17
Living in Fame versus This is England
Quite an interesting pairing and if memory serves (or I could just double check) This is England is the only song from the last Clash album to make it into round two, which probably surprises only a small minority of you. I’ve a feeling that through the randomness of the draw that it will make it through to round three now as well. Both songs however will have their fans but there are many who say that famous line that ‘This is England” was the last great Clash song, whether enough people feel that way to see it make the final sixteen remains to be seen. I’m not one of them, in fact I think Living in Fame is a song I’ve returned to more frequently in the intervening years. I should profess though that I’m not in a position to be as objective as I should be about The Clash Mark II, without Mick Jones or Topper Headon I struggle still to hear them as the same band but I appreciate that’s only one opinion.
Form Book
Round 1 – Living in Fame squeaked past The Harder They Come with 51% of the vote
Round 1 – This is England beat Version City with 67% of the vote
So neither song had especially impressive wins in round one, particularly the former so it might be a vote of attrition. I’m never sure how these things turn out but the first round round results suggest Living in Fame may struggle to get 30% of the vote. I hope it is a lot closer than that.
Stuff
The cynic in me would probably include This is England in what I plan to do later – The (post) Clash Cup which would throw together B.A.D., Joe’s solo work, Carbon Silicon, Mescaleros and assorted bits although I’m not sure how confusing the prospect might be. Although it would be interesting I think. This is England to be fair does have some wonderful lyrics but I can’t get far beyond the production and drum machine. Living in Fame, what can I say? How many ‘rock’ bands have not just good but close to excellent dub versions of their songs appearing on albums? I actually like Living in Fame as much as If Music Could Talk and I hope it (along with other tracks) destroys any concept that The Clash just plugged into dub music and stole a few ideas. Clash sound sweeter. (RIP Mikey Dread)
Before you vote I usually link to a few versions to get you in the mood although I don’t think it’s needed with these two as much. Living in Fame with cool photos by Albert Watson then — here you go. This is England sounds better as a demo and without drums, here’s the proof. I do like that version. Thanks in advance for your voting and careful consideration, there will be no coalition governments on this blog.
You can catch up with the blog in the comments, on Facebook and Twitter. You can also have a daily blog fix mailed direct with a nice glass of orange squash by subscribing to my RSS Feed here.
Which Clash Song Stays in The Clash Cup? Round 2 match 17
- Living in Fame (37%, 28 Votes)
- This is England (63%, 48 Votes)
Total Voters: 76



