Clash Cup Round 2 Match 15 (battle of the asterisks)
Good evening and welcome back to the best blog that I write, although today that might not be entirely true as you might find my other post today on Word Service Bulletins about the Tufty Club to be critical reading also. I was in the supermarket earlier and just as I was deciding upon which cereal to purchase the collective trio of snap crackle and pop asked me “when was I going to do another edition of The Clash Cup“. Alright I made that last bit up but it was when I was in that aisle then I remembered it was really overdue and hence it’s making a long-awaited comeback this evening. For the newly initiated to the blog is our ongoing quest to determine the best songs that Clash ever recorded, we began with more than 180 different tracks and an are now in round two which will get us closer to the finish line or more specifically the final 64. I’m making a pledge tonight that The Clash Cup will feature far more regular updates I have been able to find time for (the last pairing was back in December to my disgust). Let’s revisit that specific contest first of all before reviewing the next two tracks.
White Riot defeated Julie’s Been Working for the Drug Squad 67-10
Well, as you and I probably expected it wasn’t really a close run thing was it? With a margin of victory in keeping with the South Sudanese quest for independence White Riot bounces on to the final 64 (even money on it making the final 16) with the GTER track losing by a hefty distance. I think that the vast majority of songs recorded by The Clash stand up well to the test of time but for some reason “Julie’s Been Working…” has long sounded to me as if it belonged to a different era entirely. Poor thing. With the help of the random number generator I have a fresh twosome for your perusal tonight:
Clash Cup Round 2 Match 15
Deny versus The Guns of Brixton
While there I was hoping for an edge of the seat thriller in terms of two songs that are perfectly matched and then the random number machine manages to squeak out the equivalent of Wigan versus Tottenham. I know you’re thinking that Wigan can beat Tottenham but they really shouldn’t and nor should Guns of Brixton have much trouble beating Deny. Having said that I know that there is a huge level of support for all tracks that date back to 1976/1977 so it might be closer than I think. However I don’t think I’ve ever met a Clash fan who doesn’t have a special spot for Guns of Brixton which not only offers that famous and brilliant bass line but also a rare vocal appearance by Paul matched up with lyrics that are timeless in their menace.
Form Book
Round 1 – Deny lost to Innoculated City but remained due to best runner up with 44% of the vote
Round 1 – Guns of Brixton lost to Train in Vain but remained due to best runner up with 44% of the vote
So it turns out that this is almost the *asterisk matchup that we’ve all been hoping for. I allowed certain songs in round one that lost in the general voting to remain in the cup so that we would have to equally divisible ratios to see out the tournament (just like the FA cup or the college basketball March madness in the US) – thus I needed 8/16/32/64/128 tracks to allow for a straight knockout competition. Only songs that received a certain percentage of the vote were allowed to continue and as chance would have it both of these scrape through with 44%. Also worth noting that Guns of Brixton lost out to a far more difficult opponent in round one, I’ve got a feeling that Deny won’t repeat its early luck so I’m guessing Guns of Brixton will tally at least 70 percent of the vote. Match fixing allegations will not even be listened to however. Also why does my computer not accept the word Brixton? pffff….
Stuff
Personal preference? When I was 12 years old I would have chosen Deny simply because my listening skills at the time didn’t have the patience for slower or reggae tinged Clash songs. When I first heard London Calling it was my first experience of actually hearing Paul’s vocals and after being exposed to just Mick and Joe up to that point it also took a bit of getting used to. Thirty years of hindsight though have taught me that Guns of Brixton is the richer song of the two. I think it holds a fairly unique place in the fact that it wasn’t released as a single at the time of the original release of London Calling but was eventually released as a single in 1990 in both its original format and extended dub versions which made use of that famous bass line. I could write a whole post about the history of the song and subsequent uses by other acts, chances are I’ll get to that at a later time. As for Deny it was one of the five tracks that CBS ingloriously elected to remove from the original album when eventually they decided to repackage The Clash with extra singles, b-sides and a re-record of White Riot. Rotters!
Before you click the button below to vote (which you can only do once just like in Florida) I think it’s always a good idea to have one last listen to both songs that are on the chopping block. For Deny why not try this ancient and slightly slower version recorded at the Roundhouse in London in late summer 1976. For Guns of Brixton why not the Return to Brixton version just to unsettle you a bit and remind you why remixes aren’t always the best idea. This isn’t technically election rigging.
Polls will be open until Sunday and I hope you can take part and perhaps explain your vote in the comments section. Back with more soon – have a splendid day/night etc. Please share this one as voting is our right!! Tim
Which Clash Song Stays in The Clash Cup? Round 2 match 15
- Deny (19%, 17 Votes)
- The Guns of Brixton (81%, 72 Votes)
Total Voters: 89







